7:40 AM 12/20/2018 - Trump is no Putin's Puppet! That is why he is withdrawing from Syria! What other proves do you need?

From left, Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, and Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu shake hands after a meeting about Syria in Geneva, Switzerland, on Tuesday. 

Trump is no Putin's Puppet! 

That is why he is withdrawing from Syria!
What other proves do you need?

Trump's withdrawal from Syria is victory for Iran and Russia, experts say

Thursday December 20th, 2018 at 6:04 AM

1 Share

Breaking News Emails

Get breaking news alerts and special reports. The news and stories that matter, delivered weekday mornings.

By Dan De Luce, Josh Lederman and Courtney Kube

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump's abrupt decision to withdraw U.S. troops from Syria will be hailed as a victory in Russia and Iran and a betrayal among Kurdish and Arab opposition forces that have waged a seven-year war against the Damascus regime, experts and former officials say.

Although Russian and Iranian forces had already turned the tide of the civil war in favor of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad, the presence of U.S. troops has served as an obstacle to their ambitionsand a source of leverage for Washington in any potential political settlement of the conflict.

Just within the last week, senior U.S. officials had argued that the American military mission was needed to ensure the lasting defeat of ISIS militants and to serve as a bulwark against Iran.

But with Trump's move to pull out the U.S. troops, Russia and particularly Iran — which sent thousands of proxies and its own elite forces into Syria — stand to emerge as the dominant players in a country that shares a border with Israel.

The withdrawal, if carried out, will "provide Iran with solid control over the entire arc of the Levant from Baghdad to Beirut," said Nicholas Heras, Middle East security fellow at the Center for a New American Security think tank.

Iran already wields significant influence next door in Iraq, where it has heavily backed Shiite militias and cultivated close ties to the Shiite-ruled government.

Israel's ambassador to the United Nations, Danny Danon, said the presence of Iranian forces in Syria posed a threat to his country.

"We have our concerns about Syria, about the presence of Iranian troops in Syria. And we will do whatever is necessary to protect our people regardless if you have American troops, Russian troops, or any other nations," Danon told reporters.

The roughly 2,000 U.S.troops in Syria, first deployed in 2015 on President Barack Obama's watch, helped Kurdish-led forces deliver a resounding defeat against Islamic State extremists that at one point held large swaths of territory. Now the Islamic State is severely damaged and is holed up in the Euphrates River valley.

But senior U.S. officials and commanders have warned that the fight against ISIS is not over and that without more help and training from American troops, the extremists could regroup and return to the fray.

The U.S. military's top officer, Gen. Joseph Dunford, said this month that training for local forces in Syria was still at an early stage, while stabilization efforts still had "a long way to go."

Kurdish forces in Syria, which proved a reliable partner for the U.S. military's fight against ISIS, will almost certainly feel betrayed by Trump's move, experts said, and will now face a potential onslaught by Turkish forces that could jeopardize their hold on territory in the northeast.

"The U.S. withdrawal means handing over our necks to Turkey's knives," said a Syrian Kurd, speaking to NBC News from the town of Rmelan in northeastern Syria, near the Abu Hajar air base used for years by U.S. forces.

"My mother is crying on the phone. I feel that my heart will stop," he said, speaking on condition of anonymity out of concern for his safety.

Arab opposition forces fighting the Syrian regime also have relied heavily on U.S. special operations forces to help pinpoint air raids and to guide them on the battlefield. Once the American commandos leave, the Arab fighters could be vulnerable to Assad regime forces, Russian warplanes, and Iran-backed fighters as well as ISIS militants, experts and officials said.

A contingent of the Arab fighters is stationed at a key base set up by U.S. troops in the southeast. The Al-Tanf base straddles a strategic route that links Baghdad with Damascus and Beirut. U.S. officers privately refer to it as a "speed bump" for both terrorists and Iran's proxy forces.

Even by the standards of the impulsive Trump presidency, the decision came as a shock to American allies and to his Cabinet, raising fresh questions abroad about America's reliability.

Trump opted to withdraw U.S. troops despite opposition from nearly every member of his national security team. In an indication of the chaotic, last-minute nature of the move, top lawmakers, administration officials and foreign allies were blindsided by the announcement. Even the U.S. special envoy for Syria, Joel Rayburn, was caught off guard, and had to cancel his attendance at a private event Wednesday morning in Syria just a few minutes in advance, said a source familiar with the matter.

The withdrawal puts members of the Trump team in the uncomfortable position of breaking the promise of a continued U.S. presence in Syria that reassured U.S. allies such as Israel, the Kurds and Gulf Arab states. The president's recently named special representative for Syria engagement, Amb. James Jeffrey, had said repeatedly and publicly as recently as this week that the U.S. was not walking away from Syria and that the military would stay.

Ironically for Trump, who has sought to portray his foreign policy as the opposite of Obama's, the decision prompted comparisons to his predecessor. As a candidate, Trump hammered Obama for being the "creator of ISIS" because Obama had withdrawn U.S. troops from Iraq, a decision blamed for creating a power vacuum that allowed ISIS to take hold and then spread to Syria.

"This is Obama 2.0," said Mark Dubowitz, head of the hawkish Foundation for Defense of Democracies, which has urged the administration to remain in Syria as a counterweight against both the Islamic State and Iran. "It's amazing how Trump just doesn't understand how the guy he doesn't want to be like, he's being exactly like."

Less clear is why Trump decided now to withdraw, and for what reasons.

Although Trump had expressed impatience with the U.S. presence in Syria dating back to his time as a candidate, his aides and foreign leaders had convinced him to stay. After Trump earlier this year mused about pulling out during midterm campaign rallies, senior military leaders joined foreign countries including Israel, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates in a full-court press to him to hold off, officials and others briefed on the conversations said.

But Trump had long been pushed to pull out by Turkey, a NATO ally at odds with the U.S. in Syria over American backing for Kurdish forces that the Turks consider terrorists. Turkey's influence with the U.S. has increased in recent weeks following the release by Turkey of American pastor Andrew Brunson and by the murder in Istanbul of journalist Jamal Khashoggi in the Saudi consulate by a hit team sent by Saudi Arabia's government.

Trump's hopes of maintaining close U.S. ties to Saudi Arabia and its young leader Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman gave additional leverage to Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, whose government adeptly demonstrated that it had damning intelligence about the killing that could be either leaked or kept quiet.

A turning point for Trump appears to be his phone call Friday with Erdogan, which a U.S. official said had made clear that Trump was never truly committed to staying in Syria. Another senior administration official who briefed reporters Wednesday said that Trump had merely informed Erdogan in the call of a decision he'd already made.

Although it's unclear what else Trump and Erdogan may have agreed to during the call, a number of thorny issues between Turkey and the U.S. appear to be heading toward resolution at the same time.

Erdogan had been threatening an imminent new military operation into Syria, where Turkish attacks against Kurds could have risked a potentially deadly confrontation with U.S. troops who are working in close quarters with the Kurdish fighters. Trump's decision to withdraw averts that risk.

Washington has also been at odds with Turkey over its planned purchase of the S-400 missile defense system from Russia, which would trigger U.S. sanctions on Turkey and pose major problems for NATO. Late Friday, the State Department announced plans to approve a sale of U.S.-made Patriot missiles — an alternative to the S-400 — to Turkey's government.

It's unclear whether Turkey will agree to drop its S-400 sale and purchase only the American-made Patriot missiles instead. Nor is it clear whether the timing of the approval, just before Trump's Syria decision, was coincidental.

Two congressional aides said that the proposal to sell the missiles to the Turks had been awaiting informal sign-off from top lawmakers overseeing foreign affairs for some time. They said that the last remaining holdout, Sen. Bob Menendez, D.-N.J., had finally given his permission for the sale on Tuesday following efforts to persuade him by Secretary of State Mike Pompeo and others.

Dan De Luce

Dan De Luce is a reporter for the NBC News Investigative Unit. 

Josh Lederman

Josh Lederman is a national political reporter for NBC News.

Courtney Kube

Courtney Kube is a national security and military reporter for NBC News, covering the Pentagon, U.S. military operations all over the world, and intelligence and national security issues.

Abigail Williams contributed.

Read the whole story

· · · · · · ·

If it is indeed so, then thank you, Mr. Comey! - M.N. - In My Opinion: We as a nation have to be grateful and eternally indebted to him.

Wednesday December 19th, 2018 at 11:42 AM

The FBI News Review

1 Share

If it is indeed so, then thank you, Mr. Comey! - M.N. - In My Opinion

M.N.: If Comey indeed did that: ensnared Flynn, Papa-whom-dopa-los, and others; then we as a nation have to be grateful and eternally indebted to him: he not only exposed the lying and the deceptive tendencies in the "high circles", but also helped the incoming Trump Administration to maintain the adequate collective IQ and Cleanliness Index, so to speak. Gen. Flynn was prepared "to consider" the politically tinged extradition of Gulen in exchange for about $500,000 to his newly minted firm, "Flynn Intel Group", through the recently arrested, "hard to know whose agent" Kian. 
If it is indeed so, then thank you, Mr. Comey for all your tactics, and all your Jesuit cunning, they are completely appropriate, justified, and well used in this particular case, and in the other similar cases. 
My humble concern was of the opposite nature: that Comey was too busy riding his high horse and too un-involved as a leader to notice all that dirt on the low road. Apparently, the picture is much more complex, and it needs the accurate and objective study. 

P.S. And the price doesn't seem to be quite right, General. It looks more like a line from the old, broken, outdated, and somewhat mysterious military calculator, with all the numbers and value systems and symbols mixed up. Not an easy case to unravel. 

Next Customers Bitte!

Michael Novakhov

12.19.18 

comey - Google Search

comey - Google Search

Wednesday December 19th, 2018 at 8:56 AM

"Comey" - Google News

1 Share

Comey to House: Flynn Wasn't Entrapped. He Lied—And We Knew ...

Fortune-15 hours ago

The House Oversight and Judiciary Committees released a transcript Dec. 18 of former FBI Director James Comey's closed-door testimony from ...

Transcript unveiled of former FBI Director James Comey's closed-door ...
WPIX 11 New York-15 hours ago

James Comey defends FBI's interview of Michael Flynn, transcript shows
International-CNN-16 hours ago

Comey defends FBI interview of Flynn against charges of bias against ...
Opinion-Washington Post-12 hours ago

Comey told lawmakers Flynn was feeding Pence information on ...
In-Depth-Daily Mail-13 hours ago

Transcript of Comey's interview with House committees released
International-New York Post-13 hours ago

View all

Former FBI chief James Comey hits out at Trump's 'lies', urges ...

The Straits Times-Dec 17, 2018

WASHINGTON (AFP) - Former FBI director James Comey lashed out at Donald Trump on Monday (Dec 17) for telling "lies" and undermining ...

White House hits back at Comey after he criticises GOP
The Sydney Morning Herald-19 hours ago

Sarah Huckabee Sanders launches insane attack on James Comey ...
Salon-Dec 18, 2018

James Comey Slams the Republican Party After Second Interview on ...
International-TIME-Dec 17, 2018

James Comey savages Trump and his 'Republican acolytes' after ...
In-Depth-Daily Mail-Dec 17, 2018

Comey slams Trump, 'shameful' House Republicans after 2nd Capitol ...
International-CNN-Dec 17, 2018

View all

FOX NEWS FIRST: How Flynn could still avoid prison; Comey grilled ...

Fox News-3 hours ago

The measure will go to the House, where it is expected to be approved quickly; Fired FBI Director James Comey was grilled by House GOP ...

Withdrawal from Syria proves that Trump is a Putin's puppet - Google Search

Thursday December 20th, 2018 at 6:36 AM

"Withdrawal From Syria Proves That Trump Is A Putin's Puppet" - Google News

1 Share

Donald Trump proves he's no Putin puppet

Boston Herald-Oct 22, 2018

Donald Trump proves he's no Putin puppet ... President Trump's announcement Saturday the U.S. is withdrawing from the decades-old ... tour during his time in the West Wing while subsequently ignoring “Red Lines” in Syria, ...

'A very dangerous step': Russian anger at Trump's plan to withdraw ...
thejournal.ie-Oct 21, 2018

View all

Donald Trump proves he's no Putin puppet

Boston Herald-Oct 22, 2018

Donald Trump proves he's no Putin puppet ... President Trump's announcement Saturday the U.S. is withdrawing from the decades-old ... tour during his time in the West Wing while subsequently ignoring “Red Lines” in Syria, ...

'A very dangerous step': Russian anger at Trump's plan to withdraw ...
thejournal.ie-Oct 21, 2018

View all

Pompeo Defends Trump With 'Proof' of Administration's Actions vs ...

New York Times-Jul 25, 2018

WASHINGTON — Mike Pompeo, the secretary of state, told skeptical senators on Wednesday that the Trump administration has taken a ...

The Putin-Trump Helsinki Summit: The Action Is in the Reaction
International-Mintpress News-Jul 26, 2018

Donald Trump's New World Order

The New Yorker-Jun 11, 2018

Under pressure from Netanyahu and Trump, Egypt withdrew its ... The Trumptransition team proved woefully unprepared to carry out its task, ..... to curry Putin'sfavor was to insure that the Israeli military could fly in Syrian ...

A Theory of Trump Kompromat

The New Yorker-Jul 19, 2018

The former C.I.A. operative Jack Devine watched Donald Trump's performance standing next to Vladimir Putin in Helsinki on Monday, and his ...

Will Trump Be Meeting With His Counterpart — Or His Handler?

New York Magazine-Jul 10, 2018

Trump praised Putin's toughness and called for a thaw in relations ... were alleged (but not proved) to have taken funding under the table, too.

Netanyahu and Putin defuse crisis after Syria downs Russia warplane

News24-Sep 18, 2018

Netanyahu and Putin defuse crisis after Syria downs Russia warplane ..... 15 and would entail a withdrawal of all jihadist fighters from the area.

What Putin Really Wants

The Atlantic-Dec 11, 2017

A businessman who is high up in Putin's United Russia party said over an espresso ... “No one believed in Trump, not even a little bit,” Soldatov says. ..... “If [SyrianPresident Bashar al-Assad] has to go, then who comes in, in place of Assad? ..... But the rush of patriotism provided by the Crimean annexation proved fleeting.

Watch again: Trump and Putin address the media after Helsinki summit

euronews-Jul 16, 2018

Can you name a single fact that would definitively prove collusion? ... Trumpcongratulated Putin on the World Cup, which he said was "one of ...

When it comes to foreign policy, Congress must rein Trump in

The Guardian-Apr 24, 2018

It is an understatement to say that Trump's foreign policy so far has been ... with veto-proof majorities; so far Congress has rejected Trump's attempts to ... From responding to Russian aggression to US policy on Syria to the status of ..... Can we believe that Trump, for that matter, isn't just another puppet also ...

Suspended Animation in the Age of Trump

The Atlantic-Oct 8, 2018

There's hard-and-fast proof that Trump's innermost circle was more than willing .... that election year—I published a piece titled “Putin's Puppet.

Trump, Putin, and the New Cold War

The New Yorker-Feb 24, 2017

As early as 2007, Trump declared that Putin was “doing a great job in rebuilding ..... Shirreff observes that nato's withdrawal of military forces from Europe .... satirized Yeltsin and other Kremlin leaders on a puppet show called “Kukly. ..... the anarchy and violence that erupted in Libya and Syria as proof that, ...

Trump: Manafort trial is a 'very sad day for our country'

Politico-Aug 17, 2018

President Donald Trump on Friday refused to say whether Paul Manafort, his former campaign chairman who's been wrapped up in the special ...

Putin: Russian troops to withdraw from Syria

BBC News-Mar 14, 2016

Russian President Vladimir Putin says the "main part" of Russia's armed forces in Syria are to leave. In the surprise announcement, Mr Putin said his military ...

Mueller unveils more proof Manafort led Ukraine lobbying in US

Politico-Jun 12, 2018

Special counsel Robert Mueller made public new evidence Tuesday that former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort directed an ...

Don Jr.: 'It would be stupid' for Trump to sit down with Mueller

Politico-Jun 14, 2018

Donald Trump Jr. on Thursday offered his father a piece of advice on his 72nd birthday: Don't sit down for an interview with special counsel ...

Russians arrested in anti-Putin protests ahead of presidential ...

ABC Local-May 5, 2018

Mr Putin won a landslide re-election victory in March, extending his grip ... "We've come out here to demonstrate against the puppet elections," he said. ... pride and expanded Moscow's global clout with interventions in Syria and Ukraine. ... US begins withdrawal of troops from Syria as Trump declares IS ...

Trump to Suspend Military Exercises on Korean Peninsula

New York Times-Jun 11, 2018

But Mr. Trump said economic sanctions against North Korea would remain in place. .... So far Trump has failed to prove himself a dealmaker.” ...

Russian firm accused of funding US election trolling disputes Mueller ...

Politico-May 14, 2018

A Russian firm with ties to an ally of President Vladimir Putin is challenging ... Typically, criminal election law violations require proof that the defendant ... Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump or undermine Democratic ... Republicans rip Trump's surprise Syria withdrawal in meeting with Pence ...

Syria: House of Cards, Putin style

Aljazeera.com-Mar 16, 2016

Vladimir Putin's unpredicted announcement of a withdrawal of the "main part" of Russian ... ALSO READ: Did Putin trump Obama in Syria? ... Russia proved how indispensable it was to the resolution of the Syria crisis. ... seriously in Geneva, or for Assad to move aside for a more acceptable Putin puppet?

Why Russia and the West can't get along

ABC Local-Dec 19, 2017

Russian President Vladimir Putin is the man many Russians credit with not .... a "Western-sponsored coup d'etat to install a puppet fascist, neo-Nazi Junta in our ... It's not hard to see why Donald Trump admires Putin. ... it serves to prove his point, further strengthening his hand with his domestic audience.